For my latest slides on Retrieval Practice from the ATM & MA 2019 Conference, please see: Making Maths Stick – Colleen Young April 2019 (PowerPoint version) or Making Maths Stick – Colleen Young April 2019 for a pdf.
All the resources and reading from the presentation can be found below.
Retrieval Practice is not all about quizzes – low stakes quizzes play an important part but there are many other ways to help your students get the learning out! We spend much time thinking about how to get the learning in – think in your lesson planning how to get the learning out of your students! How can you help them actively recall and apply their learning?
Join the conversation on the book Make It Stick on Facebook.
If you are looking for particular resources or have questions/suggestions/observations, please contact me.
The slides include all the various resources I mentioned including SENECA Learning which looks excellent.
Links to the resources and further reading:
Rosenshine’s ‘Principles of Instruction‘ provides a very valuable list of research strategies teachers should know about and I believe it is well worth asking ourselves if we are incorporating these strategies regularly into our lessons. This UNESCO pamphlet on the Principles offers further reading and for a very clear summary of these principles of instruction, see from TeachingHOW2s this excellent summary; stick this poster on your walls! (Alternative version – yellow background).
Links and Further Reading
- Is the Feedback You’re Giving Students Helping or Hindering? Dylan Wiliam, 2014
- What Makes Great Teaching Review of the underpinning research. Robert Coe, Cesare Aloisi, Steve Higgins and Lee Elliot Major, October 2014
- Students on good Maths Teachers
- Aural Tests
- Desmos Graphing Calculator
- Learn to use WolframAlpha includes many useful examples including queries for younger students.
- Here’s the Diagram, What’s the Question?
- Algebra Snippets
- Good Mathematicians Can Go Backwards!
- Problems and Activities
- SSDD Problems
- TES Collective Memory
- A Box – GCSE Revision Activity
- Underground Maths
- Variation Theory from Craig Barton
- Access Maths – Revision Resources
A really useful source of questions which can be used for Aural tests are the mental tests from CIMT; these are included with their resources for Years 7, 8 and 9 and also for GCSE. For Key Stage 3 (ages 11-14) scroll down this page for the Year 7, Year 8 and Year 9 course material, the resources include mental tests as part of the teacher support material. On the GCSE page scroll down to the teacher support material and note the mental tests available for most units, see this on Formulae for example.
It is possible to save a particular selection of topics as the URL for your selection will be generated. It is also possible to drag the panels so your questions are displayed in the desired order. The beginning of a lesson can be an ideal time to review previous learning, starters like this can be ideal.
Included with Spot the mistake we have excellent resources from Andy Lutwyche, look at his excellent Erica’s Errors series and if we check on TES, these free resources also include plenty of errors from Clumsy Clive! I have found these work really well in class.
Also from Andy Lutwyche try his excellent Building Blocks series which have questions to take students through the various skills required for each topic and his series of ‘The answer is …What was the question?’ resources. A variety of topics are covered and all answers are provided.
On a similar theme, we could also use David Morse’s First Steps series on Maths4Everyone. This is an outstanding and comprehensive set of resources for Primary and Secondary. Note What’s New at the top of the site where you can keep an eye on the latest additions to the collection. The Click-to-zoom feature of the Worksheet collection works so well for display on screen.
Note the menu on the right-hand side to help you find exercises.
As Jess says, text exercises can become too varied too quickly, so perhaps try some minimally different problems to explore what happens with these small changes.
From OCR, their GCSE Check in tests are useful for KS3 as well as GCSE. Consider the language of functions, for example, the first questions could be used with students as young as Year 7. Full details of the Check in tests can be found in the Teachers’ Guide. Each test is of a similar format in that Questions 1-5 cover procedural calculations (AO1), questions 6-8 require the ability to reason and communicate mathematically (AO2) and questions 9-10 relate to problem solving tasks (AO3). There is also an extension task. Very usefully (thank you OCR) the Check in tests are also available in Word Format. Check in tests are also available for A Level.
With all A Level courses now linear, Retrieval Practice is essential. From crashMaths these AS Maths Key Skills Check worksheets are very valuable for Year 13 in the second year of their A Level course. The Skills Checks are all on Pure Mathematics. My Year 13 students have now completed several of these as starters and appreciate them very much. I have found I can snip the questions and get 4 copies on an A4 sheet – so very economical too!
Noting the link (on the left) to Answers and Full Worked Solutions, I was curious to see this document. Access to this resource requires registration (free) which I would highly recommend as this free resource is simply excellent. In 146 pages, the questions and fully worked solutions for each section are provided, the categories are ‘Target your revision’, ‘Exam-style’ and ‘Review’ questions. Whilst the document refers to the book, it is complete in itself. I do have and like this book, it is clear, attractively presented and written by very experienced authors. The companion Applied book, similarly has fully worked solutions.
A very useful resource is this booklet of sample questions which has been created as part of a project funded by the NCETM on Questioning the use of Bloom’s Taxonomy. I have tried many of these in the classroom, they really make students think and encourage a deep understanding. Not just for Maths but applicable to any subject I’d recommend very highly the Brighton and Hove Assessment for Learning project – Questions worth asking. This includes many practical suggestions for the classroom and concludes with a self-analysis. The project includes the use of Bloom’s Taxonomy as an aid to thinking about the level of challenge/thinking required for a question.
SENECA Learning is a free revision and homework platform, Seneca has applied research in cognitive neuroscience and psychology to provide an engaging environment for students. To answer the question What is Seneca? we can turn to this blog post from Stephen Wilks.
Key Stage 3 and Exam Board specific GCSE content is available, my students have tried this and reacted very favourably; the step by step explanations and examples are very helpful indeed. My students certainly liked the AQA Maths sections we looked at – they also use the many other subjects available.
- Research in 100 Words, Chris Moyse
- Improving Students’ Learning With Effective Learning Techniques: Promising Directions From Cognitive and Educational Psychology John Dunlosky, Katherine A. Rawson, Elizabeth J. Marsh, Mitchell J. Nathan, and Daniel T. Willingham
- Retrieval Practice website subscribe (free) for research, resources and tips
- Retrieval Practice Library (guides to download)
- Retrieval Practice Guide to Make It Stick book
- Join the conversation on Make It Stick on Facebook
- Make it Stick Summary – Markham Teaching and Learning Blog
- Retrieval Practice Research Snapshots
- What Works, What Doesn’t
- Highlighting is a Waste of Time
- Learn How To Study Using Retrieval Practice, Learning Scientists, June 2016,
- How Should Students Revise? Carl Hendrick
- What is worth reading for teachers interested in research? Professor Robert Coe, June 2016
- 7 Recommendations to Improve Student Learning based on Pashier et al, 2007 – Organising Instruction & Study to Improve Student Learning, Belmont Teach
- Test-Enhanced Learning in the Classroom: Long-Term Improvements From Quizzing – 2011, Henry L. Roediger III, Pooja K. Agarwal, Mark A. McDaniel, and Kathleen B. McDermott Washington University in St. Louis, 2011
- Retrieval as a Memory Modifier: an interpretation of negative recency and related phenomena.
Robert A Bjork, 1975
- Who’s the most tested one of all? Tim Oates, 2016
- How to Remember Anything Forever-ish by Nicky Case, October 2018, an interactive comic on the Art and Science of Memory.